Current:Home > InvestJudge likely to be next South Carolina chief justice promises he has no political leanings -ProWealth Academy
Judge likely to be next South Carolina chief justice promises he has no political leanings
View
Date:2025-04-15 02:56:44
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The only candidate running to be South Carolina’s top judge defended the state’s method of having lawmakers fill the state’s bench, saying appointees are ethical and qualified.
John Kittredge laid out his vision for being chief justice Monday at the first meeting this month of the state Judicial Merit Selection Commission. He didn’t face extremely adversarial questions and committee members noted he did not have an unusual number of critical comments from public questionnaires.
A 32-year veteran of all four levels of South Carolina state courts, Kittredge is running to replace Chief Justice Donald Beatty when he is required to retire for age next summer.
Kittredge said he has no political leanings and respects the separation of powers that gives the General Assembly the role of creating public policy. “Judges adjudicate. Judges do not legislate,” he said.
“I have tried diligently to apply the law fairly. I am apolitical and I believe that with every fiber of my being,” Kittredge said.
Several aspects of the South Carolina judiciary are under increasing scrutiny. All five members of the Supreme Court are men, the only state high court in the nation without a woman.
The court ruled 3-2 against a more severe abortion ban in January before lawmakers made a few tweaks. A newly appointed justice sided in favor of the law and another justice switched his vote, allowing the state to enforce the new ban on abortions when cardiac activity is detected, around six weeks into pregnancy.
The composition and role of the Judicial Merit Selection Commission itself is also being debated. South Carolina’s Legislature elects judges and the commission — made up of six lawmakers who are all lawyers and four private attorneys — decides whether candidates are qualified and narrows the field to three if necessary.
Critics of the system want legislators who are lawyers off the panel because they might appear before the judges they screen. There also are suggestions to have the governor nominate judge candidates and then have the General Assembly vote.
“Whether this commission should exist at all is a question for another day and another forum,” said Republican Rep. Micah Caskey, who is the chairman of the panel.
That question may start getting answered Tuesday. Caskey is one of 13 House members on a special commission that will begin hearings on whether to change how judge candidates are brought before the Legislature. The panel is also tasked with deciding whether to recommend more training and higher qualifications for lower level magistrates and steps that could enhance the public’s confidence in the judicial system.
Kittredge will testify before that committee. But for now, he said he didn’t want to say much. He did defend the way South Carolina chooses judges, saying all the money that enters public elections undermines fairness and trust in the system. He also defended the people who make it through the screening and are elected to the bench.
“The people you elect, the men and women to the bench of this state, the overwhelming majority are good and decent people of high ethics,” Kittredge said.
Kittredge promised if he is elected, he wants to make the Supreme Court act faster both in deciding what cases it will hear and issuing opinions after those hearings. He promised more transparency and accountably, especially with disciplinary matters and hearings for attorneys accused of wrongdoing.
“We can have a wonderful system, but if the public doesn’t believe it’s fair, it’s not,” Kittredge said “Perception is a reality.”
Over 10 sessions in November, the commission will talk to about 85 judge candidates ranging from Family Court and Circuit Court through the Court of Appeals and the state Supreme Court.
veryGood! (6)
Related
- DoorDash steps up driver ID checks after traffic safety complaints
- Do wealthy countries owe poorer ones for climate change? One country wrote up a bill
- Get 2 Peter Thomas Roth Invisible Priming Sunscreens for Less Than the Price of 1
- Why experts say you shouldn't bag your leaves this fall
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Here's Why Love Is Blind's Paul and Micah Broke Up Again After Filming
- Madison Beer Recalls Trauma of Dealing With Nude Video Leak as a Teen
- Sophia Culpo Shares Her Worst Breakup Story One Month After Braxton Berrios Split
- New data highlights 'achievement gap' for students in the US
- 12 Makeup Products With SPF You Need to Add to Your Spring Beauty Routine
Ranking
- Former Syrian official arrested in California who oversaw prison charged with torture
- Federal money is now headed to states for building up fast EV chargers on highways
- Treat Your Skin to Luxury With a $54 Deal on $121 Worth of Josie Maran Skincare Products
- Are climate change emissions finally going down? Definitely not
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- FAQ: What's at stake at the COP27 global climate negotiations
- Aaron Carter’s Team Recalls Trying to Implement a Plan to Rehabilitate After Cause of Death Determined
- The Way Chris Evans Was Previously Dumped Is Much Worse Than Ghosting
Recommendation
Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
Selling Sunset Season 6 Finally Has a Premiere Date and Teaser
The first day of fall marks the autumn equinox, which is different from a solstice
Coping with climate change: Advice for kids — from kids
Stamford Road collision sends motorcyclist flying; driver arrested
Climate activists want Biden to fire the head of the World Bank. Here's why
A Twilight TV Series Is Reportedly in the Works
Kylie Jenner Reveals If She's Open to Having More Kids